Sunday 9 November 2014

Scribbler's Corner! By Adeeba Ahmad

Today's special!
How often do we hear that education should be free for all, literacy rate must go up and that government is not doing enough, this is not only Pakistan's issue but also in almost all developing countries.

Interestingly enough, when we delve into the educational policies of these countries, we cannot be more impressed, then where lies the fault? Implementation and good              governance , that is what is lacking. Not just the will to deliver is required but also the means. Now you must be thinking, where there is a will there is a way, ahhh well yes,   how I wish we could get the job done with clich'es only!
Just do it!
Implementation has to be done meticulously  alongside checks and balances, otherwise corruption takes over and we are left with the current state of affairs. The good news for Pakistan is that after the 18th amendment,  provinces are autonomous in devising and   implementing their education policies. Why is this good, you may ask, well, this takes   away the tussle between federal and province units. The provinces can design the          appropriate curriculum according to their context and implement it too. They can         mobilize and train their manpower to implement it , the governance body must involve  federal and provincial representatives.

The Big Fish!
Having said this, there are so many issues in each province, for example, local bodies/   jirga elders/bureaucrats/religious leaders and political point scorers jump in and either   object to the curriculum/infrastructure decisions and then the process is halted or           delayed. Getting all these stakeholders on the same page is by far, no easy task, however it is not impossible. I believe that the policy makers must not only design a policy but   also provide the roadmap and which then needs to get approved and made into a law,     this would  bind the stake holders together and implementation can take place.
Go Global!
Apart from generating our own resources and manpower, there are various international agencies willing to help and provide support in different areas of education, namely     world bank, USAid programes etc. Although they are met with a lot of criticism too that they have their own ulterior motives, but who doesn't?
All too Private!
Think about the fact that our  very own Pakistani private school owners. What are they doing? Capitalizing on the  opportunity for business; the not- so- good state of               education is good enough chance for them in the name of filling the educational void!  Even if   we believe ourselves to be  naive enough, we can at least ask them to use their resources to adopt a school located   in the 'katchi abadi's', not just raising charity         money (read asking parents ) once a year!Most of these schools, specially in the affluent part of Karachi city, have total authority as they please, be it admission fee or monthly  tuition   fee raises or field trip/sports day/   annual concert/carnival charges or overheads, there is no stopping them, and any parent 'dare' question them, is met with dire             consequences! They can remove a child immediately in the middle of the term (and we  think they care about their students!)they can put a ban  on any parent such as  attending any of their  child's school function for years on end because that parent had the            courage to challenge their decision.Yet we rush to leave our kids in their hands even      though we rarely see a trained teacher in these schools the only criteria of getting a job   in a private school is, spoken English fluency(which is by the way again a rarity).


Seal the Deal!
Coming back to true and tangible benefits of the reformed educational policies, we can only reap the fruits if we include teacher training as a core ingredient of implementing, otherwise it's just as if you buy a latest sophisticated gadget without it's manual!
Trained teachers are real teachers, I do believe in born teachers but I also believe in       sharpening, upgrading and learning teaching, as opposed to relying on your innate           teaching ability and closing your eyes to the world around you!



Think it to ink it!
Implementation of Free Education for all, as the article 25-A states, is all the more         urgently required, as the world is changing rapidly and we need to keep up pace to         compete, if we want to succeed and provide a better enlightened future for our next       generation! But are we??



25 comments:

  1. Yes that is such a valid question indeed! I would also add that also parents must do something about their woes and not just simply join the rat race!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is definitely a point to ponder, hmmm....

      Delete
  2. Adeeba, I am glad you have raised this valid issue that seeks urgent attention. The solutions you have suggested are very valuable. In addition, we need to align all the stake holders including policy makers, teachers, and parent body. Along with this step immediate professional development/ teacher training support must be provided to teachers, as if all the stake holders and significantly, the implementer-teachers are on on the same page, targeting the goal would not be a dream anymore. Furthermore, various support groups should start their role to encourage/kids and their parents to realize the significance of education. Last but not the least, the idea of community service should be promoted so that not only opulent private school owners but all well to do people could adopt a school/s or adopt students.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Tasneem, lovely suggestions you have added, I agree that adopting students would help a lot!

      Delete
  3. Thank u adeeba for raising a topic which we r a victim of. Had wonderful time reading it .Fatima MUBASHIR

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your topic is one extremely pertinent to our future and without adressing this problem there is no hope for our nation to progress. Thank you adeeba

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm glad Rabab you liked it and thank you!

      Delete
  5. Well written article! The thing i liked the most is that you have not only raised the issues but actually proposed the solutions too! I specially liked the idea of adopting a school in kachiabadis.
    I think its now time for the big private school business people to start thinking about building a nation!
    They owe it to their motherland!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for appreciating it, you have reiterated my point beautifully, so true that we all owe it to Pakistan:)

      Delete
  6. The picture of illiteracy in Pakistan is grim. Although successive governments have announced various programmes to promote literacy, especially among women, they have been unable to translate their words into action because of various political, social and cultural obstacles.
    The Pakistani government has to get its priorities right. Pakistan spends almost all its resources on defence and state security, leaving aside little for education. If it really wants improve its long-term security it should be pouring money into education, which – as It is actually the best antidote to terror.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are so right moniba, we must allocate and monitor the funds for education :!
      Loved your comment:)

      Delete
  7. The real big and sole issue of our country. I fully agree with all the suggestions given here .only will full and uninterrupted struggle will help.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Some very valid points have been raised. A very well written and articulate article, which correctly portrays the urgency and importance of adressing the problems in our education system.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is a very nice article and i really enjoyed it. We never give importance to such things. Im very impressed :)

      Delete
  9. Wow! I loved this article. It is total right. Education is crucial for a nations growth. Im very impressed :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Well I agree that 18 amendment would lead to more contextual and need based efforts, however, it might give local touch so much in the curriculum that our students would become alienated to global culture, aspects and notions.... secondly, the effectiveness of provincial initiative can only be possible if they are made autonomous having control on their decisions and resources.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Very well written. :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. Dear adeeba,
    Its good to see that you have dealt upon some pertinent problems in our existing educational system. I hope parents at large , and the owners of our prestigious school chains will find food for thought in this article of yours.'Adopting of schools' can also be done by the 'wealthier' individuals of our society from their personal resources
    Another section of educational system can only work on 'literacy programme' to open doors of awareness for all & sundry.
    Congratulations ! adeeba. Your article served. As a booster. To think for a better future.
    Zahida Saeed Haider

    ReplyDelete
  13. A very good article on a very improtant issue. The fact is that then only outcome of education should be a better future with equal opportunities.
    You have addressed very much needed issue.

    ReplyDelete
  14. we can have a never ending debate about this,but we let things slip out of our hands may be because we dare not to take stand for our rights and so others get the privilege.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I agree with your article!! The ammoun of money we give to our govermnet should be used to make schools for the poor and who can't afford it. I think these issues should be taken seriously and a lot of us should stand up to this. I'm glad you are doing that and hopefully we can help you make a change ! :)

    ReplyDelete
  16. Some really amazing stuff here !

    ReplyDelete